Help understanding output of asl-node-auth-check

AllStarLink
1 
Checking configuration:
      Info: Skipping evaluation of private node 1878
      Info: rpt.conf has configuration for: 687730
      Info: /etc/asterisk/iax.conf contains no registration lines.
      Info: /etc/asterisk/rpt_http_registrations.conf contains 1 registration line(s)
      Info: Registrations present for configured node(s): 687730
      Info: IP from https://conntest-east1.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 108.144.12.1
      Info: IP from https://conntest-west1.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 108.144.12.1
      Info: IP from https://conntest-west2.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 108.144.12.1
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-east1.allstarlink.org:4570 reports: 108.144.15.1
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west1.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: 108.144.15.1
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west2.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: 108.144.15.1
        OK: HTTP IP probes have consensus on the same perceived IP
        OK: IAX IP probes have consensus on the same perceived IP

Testing node 687730:
        OK: Node registration config is well-formed
        OK: Node registration type is HTTP
        OK: register.allstarlink.org is reachable (via HTTP)
        OK: HTTP registration state is Registered
        OK: Perceived IAX IP:PORT for this node is: 108.144.12.1:4569
        OK: Registered to aws-east1a-register1.allstarlink.org - 52.21.169.197
        OK: Server-set UDP port matches bindport in iax.conf
        OK: Node registration within 10 minutes: 2026-09-10 15:35:24 UTC
      Info: Last time IP changed was 2026-09-10 11:56:39 UTC
   Warning: Node is not perceived as registered; not tested

   Warning: Node 687730 has 1 warning(s)!
   Warning: Warnings may or may not be problems depending on configuration

What does the warning mean, what can I infer from it ? This node appears to be registered but will not connect to any other nodes. The number was recently NNXed and it's server was set to 4570.

Gerry - W6WNG

2

I need to fix a bug in the nodeping service that I keep putting off. Your node isn't reachable on your defined inbound IAX port:

https://nodeping.allstarlink.org/?node=687730

{"calleraddr":"127.0.0.1","ipv4":{"rc":-9,"status":"unreachable"},"version":"20260303.0"}
3

This node is still in trouble - I re-ran asl-node-auth-check this morning and there appear to be inconsistencies in the IAX port and WAN IP Address (it does not have port forwarding implemented, no incoming connections). 4570 is defined on the Server record and in the node config - but 2 servers are reporting 4569 ? Two different IP addresses ... CGNAT ?

Checking configuration:
      Info: Skipping evaluation of private node 1878
      Info: rpt.conf has configuration for: 687730
      Info: /etc/asterisk/iax.conf contains no registration lines.
      Info: /etc/asterisk/rpt_http_registrations.conf contains 1 registration line(s)
      Info: Registrations present for configured node(s): 687730
      Info: IP from https://conntest-east1.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 107.127.13.30
      Info: IP from https://conntest-west1.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 107.127.13.30
      Info: IP from https://conntest-west2.allstarlink.org/ip reports: 107.127.13.30
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-east1.allstarlink.org:4570 reports: 107.120.47.49
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west1.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: 107.120.47.49
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west2.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: 107.120.47.49
        OK: HTTP IP probes have consensus on the same perceived IP
        OK: IAX IP probes have consensus on the same perceived IP

Testing node 687730:
        OK: Node registration config is well-formed
        OK: Node registration type is HTTP
     Error: register.allstarlink.org is unreachable (via HTTP)
        OK: HTTP registration state is Registered
        OK: Perceived IAX IP:PORT for this node is: 107.127.13.30:4570
        OK: Registered to aws-east1a-register1.allstarlink.org - 52.21.169.197
        OK: Server-set UDP port matches bindport in iax.conf
        OK: Node registration within 10 minutes: 2026-09-11 15:43:04 UTC
      Info: Last time IP changed was 2026-09-10 23:21:51 UTC
   Warning: Node is not perceived as registered; not tested

   Warning: Node 687730 has 1 warning(s)!
   Warning: Warnings may or may not be problems depending on configuration

Gerry W6WNG

4

Yes, that's a classic example of Carrier-Grade NAT - your UDP traffic is being handled in a separate network topology from HTTP/Web traffic. Try IAX registration to see if it helps, but you likely want to move to 44Net Connect.

5

Thanks Jason ... as I suspected - I'll deploy our shared tunnel for the user ...

Gerry W6WNG

6

Are you referring to these lines?

      Info: IP from udp://conntest-east1.allstarlink.org:4570 reports: ...
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west1.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: ...
      Info: IP from udp://conntest-west2.allstarlink.org:4569 reports: ...

If so, the :4570 and :4569 references are the port #'s of our test servers.

7

Ah! thanks @WA3WCO - it was dense of me not to figure that for myself !

User is up and running on our shared tunnel, problem solved.

Onwards and upwards !

Gerry W6WNG